Pete writes:
Hello, Space Freaks. In mid November 2017 we witnessed the first of several major
auctions that encompass one of the best Vintage Star Wars collections to ever
be put on the auction block. With incredible
results across the board, the first round Hake’s Americana auction of the
Russell Branton collection certainly was an interesting event and worth
reviewing in detail.
Before we look at the auctions themselves, we should talk a
little bit about traditional live auctions, online auctions, and how Hake’s
Americana has an unusual but effective approach that differs from both.
In a live auction setting, items don’t have a set start and
end time. There is an order of the items going up on the auction block and the
hammer is struck once no bids remain. In a traditional online only auction, an item has a set start and end
time in which bidders can bid, thus an auction that ends at 8:00 will not be
taking bids at 8:01. Simple, I know, but I want to make sure that we’re all on
the same page here.
Hake’s approach is different and captures some of the good and
the bad of both worlds. Much like an
online auction, all of the items have a start and an end time. However, much like a live auction, if a bidder
makes a bid it can extend the length of the auction, thus pushing the hammer
out further as more people bid. This is
a novel concept in that key items can go hours and hours past the listed end
time of the auctions as long as people keep bidding. I’m sure this can create frustration for
those bidding if their items keep getting pushed out, however for spectators it
creates a spectacle and allows everyone to see more of the detailed bidding
behavior. The goal here like any
business is to make money, and in the end that’s what it does. By allowing the
most sought after items to continually go up in price, you give bidders the
chance to opt in and rethink their high bids -- and not over the course of
seconds, but over the course of hours. This leads to some exciting action among bidding and really changes
the game when it comes to strategy in an auction setting.
AUCTION REVIEW:
We won’t hash through all of the results as they can be
found at this link:
Rather, we’ll take a look at some of the key items from the
event and discuss the implications of one particular auction in detail. With that, let’s look at the items
themselves.
Ben Kenobi Double Telescoping MOC –
$76,700 РThe cr̬me de la cr̬me of the auction was the first of three MOC double telescoping figures that will be auctioned off across the series of
auctions. With examples selling for
six figures in the past year, this actually wasn’t the biggest head-turner of the
event from a results perspective. It was however the highest priced item at the
end of the auction and a great item to see in an environment like this, as most
of these aren’t sold through public auctions or eBay, but rather through high
end dealers and collectors. Needless to
say, having a MOC DT of Ben is an incredible sight, rarely seen, very sought
after, and ultimately extremely valuable in the world of Star Wars toys.
Anakin Skywalker
Dynacast Painted Charcoal Gray Hardcopy – $34,981.10 – Not to be
confused with its more common
first shot counterpart, this painted dynacast
hardcopy is the envy of many prototype collectors. The price seems to be a bit high, but then
again its rarity and desirability make it a unique piece especially in the “up”
market that we’re seeing in the pre-production realm.
Boba Fett AFA80
Trilogo MOC – $11,682 – We can’t say enough about how cool of a piece this
is. Its Trilogo, it has an unpainted knee, and it’s Fett -- all things that lead
to appreciation in value and high prices. A beautiful piece in incredible condition with a price tag that would
choke a goat, it was great to see this reach a high mark.
Lando Calrissian POTF
Hand-Cut Proof Card AFA90 – $5,717.69 – Given its rarity, this may have been
one of the best “deals” of the day if there were any deals to be had. A cut card from the POTF line with no
backer printed on it, it may not be one-of-a-kind but it can’t be far from
it.
Stormtrooper ESB 31-Back Proof
Card AFA90 – $8,047.60 – Although you can buy them in droves as
loose figures, when it comes to pre-production, Stormtrooper proofs can be some
of the rarest and most expensive. In
the ROTJ line the 65A which is the most common proof with a few examples of
each character in existence, the Stormtrooper is one of two that only have 2-3 examples known. When you
look at the rarity of the 31-Back proofs, this piece along with a few other characters
fits into a class all its own in terms of scarcity and demand, thus it was no
surprise that this went for big money.
Darth Vader Revenge of
the Jedi Proof Card AFA85 – $4,283.40 – With a strong ending price, this
Revenge Vader proof is one item that continues to go up and up in value over
time, in this case passing recent auctions for Boba Fett Revenge proofs in
terms of the final price. The Dark Lord of the Sith is one of the most recognizable characters in all of cinema
and in the past few years the piece has really risen in value.
The Surprises:
Greedo AFA80 21-Back – $1,535 – Kind of crazy, as when you put in
the buyer’s premium someone could have bought three of these for the same price
on eBay in a given month.
ISP-6 Mini-Rig AFA85 – $1,534 – For years I’ve been telling people in the
hobby that the ROTJ line is the superior line of the Star Wars
series and finally I have proof (J/K). Here I think we have the case of someone struggling to find the grade
they wanted and throwing out a crazy number thinking no one will actually bid
this up. Then again, MOC Boushh figures
have sold for nearly $2K in the past few years, so maybe ROTJ mini-rigs are the next big thing.
Imperial Forces AFA75 Action Figure 3-Pack – $17,133 – With all the
buzz surrounding this series of auctions, two things seem to be talked about more
then anything. First, the fact that examples of all three DT MOC figures will be
up for grabs. Second, that an entire set of 3-packs will be up for
grabs. Given the latter, I think we
have a case of someone really needing to complete a full run as the price here
is absurd! Now this is one of the most
popular of the 3-packs, but it’s not one of the rarest, and in 75 condition
it’s not that great overall. Thus, it’s
easy to say that this went way above its actual value; more so than the ISP-6,
but not as much as the auction we have yet to discuss.
Beyond Shocked…..
It goes without saying in
auctions like this that something will end up going for crazy amounts of money
comparative to their actual value or historical sales prices. While some things are surprising, others just
jump into a complete league of their own, and no this doesn’t have
anything to do with Madonna, Rosie O’Donnell, or Tom Hanks with a drinking problem...
To close up, let’s look at the auction that has caused so
much commotion on social media. Let’s look at the craziest of the crazy, the
auction that produced a number that is way out in left field on that thin
border that separates the world of the norm from the world of the extreme. Of
course, I’m talking about a term we’ve come to use many times on the MarketWatch
over the years: the lunatic fringe.
Luke Skywalker AFA95 12-Back – $50,622 – The result of this auction
poses an interesting question: “What will someone pay for the best
condition
example of the most iconic Star Wars toy of all time?” The answer is a
boatload. I mean that in a literal sense, as you could literally
buy a boat and fill it with cash for what someone dropped here.
It’s hard to argue against the notion that the
most desirable of all of the original Star Wars toys was Luke Skywalker. He’s
the main hero of the movie. His surname and its lineage became the link
that will connect 9 movies in the franchise together. And although Vader is probably the most
recognizable figure in the Trilogy, Luke was the focal point of the first three
movies and his struggle is still regarded by many to be the key thread that
pulls the Skywalker saga together.
I can’t say it’s with no
surprise that we saw this piece reach astronomical levels. In fact, without
getting into the details I have to say the number is crazy for any long time
collector. But let’s look at some of the
underlying implications, both with the results and what this could mean for the
future of these auctions and the hobby as whole.
We’ve already established the
fact that a MOC 12-Back Luke is probably the most commonly sought after piece among
MOC collectors in the hobby historically. (Yes, I know that most of you reading this are only interested in foreign
double telescoping bootlegs of characters that were never produced, but please
humor me here.)
Taking that point into the
equation, let’s take a minute to focus on the condition. Needless to say, there isn’t a lot of
transactional data around AFA sales above the grade of 90, and of what is out
there most are loose figures and proofs. Given this lack of specific data, honing in on similar auctions is
difficult, if not impossible. However, there was one example that I was able to pull from this past year. In order to go deeper than this, we move to
the next best thing available to us in terms of comparative information from other AFA95
auctions and data from other high grade auctions.
Earlier this summer some eyes rolled when an AFA95 Yoda sold on eBay for $1,981 -- a figure that that traditionally sells for
$4-$500 in AFA80 condition. This gives
us a good baseline for the Luke figure in question. This Luke example is a 12C-Back figure and an
AFA80 condition usually sells in the $1,500-$2,000 range. Taking the high end of that estimate, we
find that our AFA95 brought a 25X lift over its AFA80 brethren. Quite the stretch as we only saw a 4X lift
on the Yoda figure.
Similarly, this summer we also saw an AFA95 Chewbacca 45-Back proof card sell
for just over $2K. Given that 90 grade proofs are more attainable (comparatively speaking), we assume that the increase here wouldn’t be that much. In fact, in the past year we’ve actually seen
AFA90 examples of a Chewbacca 45-Back proof sell for more than what we saw
with the auction for the 95.
The elasticity of price with items that are clustered around
a specific grade such as proof cards has historically lead to only marginally
higher prices achieved for those pieces. Thus, an AFA 80, 85, and 90 proof card of the same character and type may
only have a 20-30% difference between the 80 and 90 examples. On the inverse, the spread on a MOC figure is
much higher with a sometimes 50-100% difference between those same grades. In short, the elasticity of price
relative to the type of collectible varies dramatically, and in the world of
Star Wars, MOCs do traditionally have the widest spread.
The aforementioned Chewbacca proof auction illustrates a point in lack of
variance in price, however there’s another underlying implication that we can
look at when it comes to these results, and it’s a point that a lot of collectors miss: it’s not just about the price
and condition, sometimes it’s about the forum. In the case of the AFA95 Chewbacca proof, the item was sold on eBay, while
the 90 proof that sold for nearly twice as much sold at Celebration. Thus,
the biggest difference was the selling environment. It changes the customer’s mindset, and it
potentially brings new buyers to the table by creating a different sense of
urgency. In the case of the $50K Luke Skywalker,
I have to believe that the forum had a profound impact on the end result.
With all of this in mind, I return to the question I posed at
the beginning of the discussion on this piece: how much is the best condition
example of the most recognizable/iconic figure in the line truly worth, and
what is someone willing to pay for it? Well, it’s going to vary...I
know that’s not the answer a lot of you want to hear, but the fact of the matter
is there are so many factors that play into an auction price that it’s almost
impossible to point a finger at one number. Rather, we have to look at all of the factors in this situation playing
together to create the perfect storm that produced a historic high and should
be seen as a win in the hobby no matter what your opinion is on the actual
results.
My personal perspective in technical terms is that this was the
most insane price ever realized for an item based on its rarity, availability,
and condition and it will probably never be repeated. That’s one person’s opinion. What do
you think? Post here or on social media at our Facebook page with thoughts on
the auctions, and what they mean for the hobby. Was it a fluke, or the new trend...
That’s all for this round, check back in a January for our
year-end round up!
Wampa Wampa,
"Fratastic" Pete
