Tuesday, March 17, 2015

Palitoy's Droid Factory: Base for Your Face!

Ron writes:

All-star guest blogger and internationally recognized sex symbol Yehuda Kleinman continues to give us great material related to worldwide toy variations. A while back he posted about the Palitoy Death Star. Here's his latest, on the Palitoy version of the Droid Factory.

Yehuda writes:

After the initial Star Wars release of 1978, Kenner remained a tough act to follow, as they continued to revolutionize the toy market with creative new ideas. In 1979 Kenner introduced American children to  the Droid Factory playset. It was the first Star Wars playset that a company produced that was never actually referenced in the movie!


The toy consisted of a large, hard, durable base with a mobile crane to move the droid parts around. It also included a few dozen droid parts, including five droid bodies, multiple droid legs, connector pieces, arm attachments, wheels, axles, and treads. All parts were interconnectable and allowed the user to build five complete droids at the same time, including an R2-D2.

The set also included:
  • A "Droid Maker Blueprints" booklet with instructions on droid building. 
  • A Kenner "We Really Do Care" order form for additional and replacement parts (this was particularly important given the inclusion of some easily lost, but very necessary, connector pins). 
  •  A sticker sheet, which included a sticker for R2's torso.
  •  A Kenner Star Wars Death Star mini-catalog.
When Palitoy was designing their version of the Droid factory, the company aimed to cut costs while maintaining the features and character of the American toy. Palitoy realized that they could not redesign the entire Droid Factory out of cheaper materials -- as they'd previously done with the Death Star Playset -- and still produce a viable product. Therefore, the toy was produced with the droid parts that were already available in the Kenner product, and all cost-cutting was achieved via production of a completely different base.



The Kenner base was made out of a thick plastic that could easily handle many hours of rough play. The plastic base was also strong enough to support the durable plastic crane that attached with a press fit in its center. Additionally, it was produced with many molded compartments to hold the assorted droid parts.


In contrast, the Palitoy base was made of a thin vacuformed plastic that was stabilized with a cardboard flat bottom. Due to the limitations of the cheaper material, the base features some significant differences. Specifically, it has more rudimentary compartments for the droid parts and is not strong enough to support a robust crane.


Palitoy compensated for these deficiencies with a simpler, minimalistic version of the crane. The large plastic stand and arm of the Kenner crane were not produced. Instead, the small black connector peg that was manufactured by Kenner to attach the crane's base to its arm was repurposed as a winch. The Palitoy base was molded with a slot on the top of the ramp portion to accommodate this peg. When a string was placed around the peg, and the peg turned, droid parts could be hauled up the ramp. Additional stickers were also added to decorate the simpler base.


If you look carefully at the right side of the playset, you can see where the Doctor visited the Palitoy Droid Factory inside a Tardis carefully disguised as a dangerous laser-welding booth.



The Palitoy set also boasts an interesting variation. Specifically, the base can be found in two different colors, blue and tan. The blue base is the one pictured in the photograph on the box, visible above. The tan version features the same type and color of plastic used on Palitoy's Land of the Jawas playset.

As with all Palitoy versions of Kenner's playsets, unique packaging was produced. Interestingly, many of the Star Wars sets share design elements similar to the Star Wars cardbacks, including a space-like black border with a starry background.


The set also features a unique version of the "Droid Maker Blueprints." The document illustrates the Palitoy version of the toy. Additionally, it came packed with the elusive Palitoy mini-catalog featuring the Death Star playset on its cover, as well as a sticker sheet. In contrast to the Kenner version, no order form for additional parts was included because, apparently, Palitoy really didn't care.


Some additional facts:
  • The Kenner Droid Factory was re-released for the Empire Strikes Back featuring an updated film logo on the packaging. The Palitoy version was never updated.
     
  • Palitoy was able to save additional production costs by repurposing preexisting toy parts from other sets, meaning they did not have to prototype new parts and create new steel molds for production. This cost-cutting method was also applied to Palitoy's Death Star, which contains two X-Wing fighter guns to be used in the gunner's chair.
     
  • As did the Kenner version, the toy included droid parts required to build an exclusive three-legged version of R2-D2. Some loose figure collectors consider the Droid Factory R2-D2 a loose variant, while others consider it simply parts from a playset. Amusingly, this R2-D2 figure is the playset's lone connection to the Star Wars films!
     
  • The Kenner and Palitoy R2-D2 stickers differ, and some collectors consider them to be distinct variants. The Palitoy version has a wavy blue line near the top of the sticker, while the corresponding line on Kenner's version is flat. The Kenner stickers also have a glossier finish.

Please stay tuned for the next installment: Palitoy: The Land of the Jawas playset!

-- Yehuda Kleinman

Sunday, March 15, 2015

MarketWatch: Too-Onebee (2-1B)


Michael L. writes:

Another background character rolls around with another period where there were plenty of sales. As always, I was able to find a good mix across the cardbacks 2-1B appears on (aside from Coin Offer stickers, which I thought I would find for sure). I found a few foreign items as well, and a nice POTF Coin. 


Having listened to the show and seen Fredrik's collection, I have gained a real appreciation for the figure. The cardback colour scheme is very appealing once combined with the colour of the figure. 

Anyway, onto the data...

I decided to try and create a game format this month. Given the show would hit the podcast airwaves in March, I decided on a March Madness ‘bracket’ format. I’ll admit it was a little confusing as I listened to the guys read it back on the show, but thought I would at least document it here on the blog. 

But before I get into the bracket, here's a summary of what we did see:

EMPIRE STRIKES BACK

41A -- I found 3 examples of his debut card, all ungraded, with prices of $109.99, $160 and $211.50

47 back -- Only 1 example which sold at $190.89

48B -- 1 graded (AFA80) selling for $262.07 and an ungraded 48C selling for $62.

RETURN OF THE JEDI

65B AFA 85 - $123.61

77 back -- A couple of ungraded MOC's selling for $76.95, $99.99 and $125.00

FOREIGN
Trilogo - ungraded $63.00

OTHER ITEMS

Micro unproduced 1st shot - $411.95, similar to that depicted in the Archive entry for this month's Nugget.

AFA85 Power of the Force Coin - $750

So that's the data summary - and this is how it was turned into a bracket format for Steve to test Skye's guessing ability on the podcast. I did think going in that the debut card was a strong chance of winning the overall bracket...

Here are the brief parameters I set up to create the bracket:
1. Two pools - Empire and Jedi (though I added a few loose graded figures into this side)
2. Pick a random eBay auction per cardback (or loose figure) to determine winner of that round
3. Can only use auction result once; i.e. then find another sale for that cardback in its next 'round'

Here are my seedings before I collected the data:

Empire Strikes Back Round 1:
 
41A ungraded v 41D ungraded 
Result: 41A ungraded ($211.50) v 41D ungraded ($175) 
Winner: 41A advances to Final 4.

47 ungraded v 48B  
Result: 47 ($190.89) v 48 ($262.07)
Winner: 48 advances to Final 4.

So this will pit an ESB 41A up against an ESB 48 back

Return of the Jedi Round 1: 
 
ROTJ 65B AFA85 v AFA90 loose
Result: ROTJ 65B AFA 85 ($123.61) v AFA90 loose ($149.99)
Winner: AFA90 loose advances to Final 4.
 
ROTJ ungraded v Foreign 
Result: ROTJ ungraded ($76.95) v Foreign (trilogo $63.00) 
Winner: ROTJ ungraded advances to Final 4.

So this will see a graded loose figure up against an ungraded ROTJ MOC in the next round.

Final 4 - Empire Strikes Back
41A v 48 
Result: 41A ($160 - ungraded) v 48 ($62 - ungraded) 
Winner: 41A advances to the championship round. 

Final 4 - Return of the Jedi
AFA Loose v ROTJ ungraded
Result: AFA Loose ($59.99) v ROTJ ungraded ($125) 
Winner: ROTJ ungraded advances to championship round.

Championship 
41A ungraded v ROTJ ungraded 
Result: 41A ($109.99 ungraded) v ROTJ ungraded ($99.99).
Winner: 41A ungraded

So, I think in summary I may well agree with Skye... the format was confusing and trying to run a bracket with Vintage Star Wars pieces just didn't quite work. But it's recorded here for prosperity.

I will return to the normal format with Luke Hoth next time. Wampa Wampa!!

Friday, March 13, 2015

Star Wars Patterns & Costumes

Amy writes:

Fabric companies have offered licensed and non-licensed Star Wars patterns for over 35 years. Here's a look back at of some of the most common and infamous patterns to hit store shelves.

Shortly after Empire Strikes Back, McCall's pattern company offered up this pattern. Masks and accessories sold separately of course.


And it wasn't just costumes that were sold as patterns but sweaters as well. Check out this unlicensed 'Star Galaxy Cardigan' we all know it's an X-Wing sweater.  That's some lucky kid right there! 


Butterick sold doll patterns for 12" dolls. You can spot the Kenner Leia on the bottom center of this pattern.  Just in case you wanted to make that school teacher outfit for your Leia doll.


And what young kid didn't want to be an Ewok for Halloween in 1983?! On second thought, after seeing this frightening pattern by McCall's... maybe not.


By the time of the prequels, we finally got licensed Star Wars patterns for adults and kids.  



But that didn't keep pattern companies from continuing what they've always done. Emulating popular costumes from film and tv with unlicensed patterns.

As a result, just in time for The Phantom Menace, we got Darth Grim Reaper his Druid apprentice and pouty kid! 


Darth Vader appears to be in disguise here as a silver luchador ready to fight with batguy. 


Simplicity released Attack of the Clones type patterns that were so convincing we'd almost think they were licensed.  


Selections for patterns dubbed with Revenge of the Sith.


 


In the future, be sure to expect even more licensed and non-licensed Star Wars patterns to show up at local fabric stores.

Wednesday, March 11, 2015

February '15 MarketWatch: Buying in Bulk

Pete writes:

Happy Spring Space Freaks! Hoping all of you are doing well coming out of the Holidays and the coldest month of Winter. The market as is usual had a very strong month in January with a lot of great unique items coming on the scene in the month, as well as strong prices for a lot of staples in our hobby. Thus, whether you were looking for something niche or just to upgrade or acquire something new on the production side, this was definitely a good month to do that.  

With Celebration Anaheim only just about 5 weeks away as of today I’m expecting to see a bit of a lull in the market leading up to the first few weeks of April. I’ll be bringing you some live coverage of Celebration Anaheim including items from the floor, room sales and one off transactions that I’m privy too. With the new movie coming out and the general excitement that comes along with each Celebration, we’re sure to see some amazing items and all time high prices coming out of the event.

This month I have a handful of auctions to look at with the theme being "collections."  Lots and collections come up regularly on eBay and we throw them into the mix on the MarketWatch every so often, but after seeing an up tick in the month of January and December I thought we’d just focus on some of these instant collections. It’s amazing what some of these sets go for and the value that some people realize in purchasing in bulk. There were literally dozens of notable collections sold in January through early February and here we bring together just a small sampling. We’ll take a look at what some loose runs go for these days, including a full set of the first 79/92 figures. In addition, we’ll switch over to the packaged world with some MOC lots, most notably a steal on a set of the first 77 MOC.

So let’s begin our coverage with where the line started -- the Original 12. Here we have a set of the Original 12 graded by AFA. The varying grades lead way to what is actually a pretty palatable price point. You have figures that would be worth roughly $3-400 loose along with grading costs of $18 a figure ($216 for all 12), leading way to a total of $850, a little high for what you might expect but in the given market not out of this world by any measure. 

AFA Graded Set of First 12 - $850
[auction link no longer available- sorry!]





We go from average to a little out of control. Whether you love or hate AFA, most everyone agrees that U-grading (removing items from the package for loose grading) is a horrible practice. In some cases it can be seen as legitimate when a figure's packaging is in pretty abysmal condition, however even that is considered a faux pas to a large portion of the collecting community. U-grading drives up the value of a lot of loose figures given the fact that these items have literally never been touched by human hands outside of the factory and the graders at AFA. This increases demand as a niche group of collectors gravitate towards this segment of collecting. Whether you like the practice or not, it does create a premium with loose figures that didn’t exist before the practice arose. Thus, no matter how hard people fight it, this practice will be around for the foreseeable future.

Outside of the U-grades themselves, what we have here is a pretty interesting little collection. Not only do we have the first 21 figures, we also have a lot of variants of these figures, and a store display for the first 21. One aspect that is somewhat comforting is the fact that some of the figure variants were never released during the original Star Wars run, so we can take some solace in knowing that these weren’t all pulled from 12 and 21 back cards, and that some did come from ESB and ROTJ cardbacks. Included in the set of variants are the three different hair colors of Farmboy Luke Skywalker, Tusken Raider with hollow cheeks, Walrusman (pink and white), Jawa (small hood and large hood), and Ben Kenobi (grey and white hair). Overall a nice representation for variant collectors but with a hefty price tag, ten times that of our starting auction.
AFA 90 Loose Lot $10,000 
Star Wars First 21+ Variants U Graded Set





Going from loose to MOC, we have our first of two auctions which were steals when it comes to buying in bulk. This auction is for 16 of the first 21 MOC with a price tag of $3,000 -- quite a bit shy of what Jordan charged one of his customers on Toy Hunter last year for the first 12 plus three 21 backs and well below the market average. The auction itself was won with a best offer and whomever got to it first surely reaped the rewards of staying on their eBay game getting these figures for an average of $187.50 each. Another auction that shows that there’s value in the hobby if you continue to stay on the key sites like eBay, as these figures graded could easily go for $7-10,000.  
Lot of 16 MOC from first 21 - $3,000
Lot of 16 of First 21 MOC



If our last auction didn’t blow your mind this one surely will: the entire run of the first 77 figures MOC on their debut cardbacks for $6,500 --  that’s right, less than $85 a piece ($84.41 to be exact). Now let me start by saying something does seem strange when you look at the listing, it’s a first time eBayer based on the feedback, and the BIN is extremely low. This does raise some questions: was this a scam? Were there fakes? Did the transaction go down smoothly?  All of which are completely valid questions given the spread between fair market value and what they actually sold for. I did contact the seller for comment but never saw a response. They could be in hiding, or just simply to embarrassed that they let a $30,000 set of figures go for 1/6th of the value. Nonetheless, let’s assume that everything was on the up and up. This would be proof positive that there are still some ways to get deep into the hobby without breaking the bank and that those who are diligent with keeping an eye on the market can make a huge score.
First 77 MOC - $6,500
First 77 MOC




              
Finishing up the month we have the largest and most expensive of the collections featured. This one's a bit less focused than others but impressive nonetheless. 90 MOC figures for an estimated $16,500, or $183 per figure. This is a great representation of someone's hard work in trying to assemble a full run of MOC figures that spans the full series from ANH to POTF. The figures in the collection are in a variety of different conditions, with a mix of graded and ungraded items. The set includes variants of certain cardbacks and a nearly complete representation of the full line. It's a great view and ultimately a great buy given the per figure cost of $183 a piece, really a steal when you think about the breadth of the collection including several 12 backs, 20 backs and POTF figures, all which carry average MOC prices of well over $200 a piece (depending on condition). Collections like this make me ask why someone would part with something like this; it seemed so close but just not there. Regardless of the reason, the collector and buyer should be proud of what was put together as it truly is a great representation of one collector's hard work and another's awesome find.
90 Figure MOC Collection - $16,500
Mixed collection of Graded and Ungraded MOC

That wraps up the update for February, check back shortly for our March update featuring single items sold in the month of January and February.  

Wampa Wampa,
FB24

Thursday, March 5, 2015

'Chive Cast 59 - Five Years of Existential Robots and Love


Come celebrate 5 years of 'Chive Casting with Skye and Steve as they talk about Star Tots with Chris Georgoulias and chat about vintage Ewok Valentines and Celebration swag with Amy Sjoberg. 2-1B, the existential robot doctor, is our figure of the month and he gets a surprise poetry slam and an interview with his biggest fan, Stockholm’s Fredrik Juthberg. We unveil some new failed features such as the questionable “Would you rather: 2-1B or not 2-1B” and an ambitious but confusing MarketWatch game. Finally, we count down the 10 biggest changes in the last half-decade of Vintage Star Wars collecting since we started the show.



Loading the player...































Image Sources and Show Note Links:

Monday, March 2, 2015

Toy Fair 2015: Get Ready for Revell!

We are happy to welcome back guest blogger Yehuda Kleinman, who recently paid a visit to Toy Fair in New York and is here to bring you the scoop.

Revell Model Kit Store Display Mock-Up


Yehuda writes:

Star Wars and New York City's annual Toy Fair event share a long and fabled history going back to the earliest days of the franchise's mythos.

The main purpose of Toy Fair has always been to afford toy manufacturers the opportunity to introduce their new lines to perspective vendors and the press. Toy Fair has seen the introduction of nearly every Star Wars toy ever produced including legendary toys like the ultimately un-produced rocket-firing Boba Fett all the way to the new Star Wars Rebels cartoon lines. 2015 is of course a special year for Star Wars and its loyal followers both old and new with the year-end release of Star Wars Episode VII: The Force Awakens.




The announcement of any new Star Wars film always brings added excitement and curiosity to Toy Fair. Often the first glimpses of new characters and future iconic toys happen at events like this, and this year will bring many new characters and for the first time in over 30 years the return of the original cast! Even though the new steward of the franchise, Disney, had remained tight lipped about details of the upcoming film until this point, this was New York Toy Fair and this could be the venue where Disney decided to let some information leak.

As I entered Toy Fair, it became immediately clear that Disney wasn't going to give up any secrets willingly yet. The only information that toy licensees were allowed to publicly show for the upcoming film where the logo and the new title The Force Awakens to show that they had obtained a license to produce merchandise for the film.


Still, there were four days and hundreds of vendors to cover and plenty of Star Wars to see (or not to see) and a lot of fun work to be done.

Although I knew I would cover the entire show, there were certain companies that would require a more in depth look because of their Star Wars focus. The more obvious toymakers in this group were Hasbro and LEGO, so I started there.

LEGO Product Display
Both toymakers focused on expansions of existing Star Wars lines without a creating any buzz about the upcoming new films, other than a sign or a wink that everything everyone expects is coming.

Of note were two nods to vintage at the Hasbro event. The expansion of the 3 3/4" action figure line for the Rebels series included the new "Imperial Troop Transport." At first I thought the displayed model was an interesting mock up piece for the later to be fleshed out production toy. I was disappointed to find out the display featured the final production toy. The new version is a cheaper, smaller version of the original. It also unfortunately lacked the original toy's quirky charm and features. Gone were the push buttons with original movie quotes and sounds, no more "immobilization hoods" or anterior compartments and, well, no more wheels… rendering the new toy into a functionless gray brick.

Rebels 3 3/4" Line from Hasbro
The second nod to vintage was really more of a nod to vintage Furby toys. The new soon to be released toy dubbed "Furbacca" ( I kid you not) appears to be the love child of a long forgotten evening between a young amorous Chewbacca and an unsuspecting Furby. The new brown-furred, bandoliered crooner hums John Williams tunes while being somewhat interactive, albeit aloof (his hah-hah sounds more like heh-heh). I must admit the furry thing made me smile more than once, but it reeked of "vintagesploitation." I was surprised it didn't also transform into Optimus Prime.

Still in the search for that old magic that Star Wars toy production and marketing had shown in the past, I continued on to the other vendors on my list.

Model building was a big part of Boys Toys culture in the 1960s and 1970s and when Star Wars was released, the franchise had risen to the challenge, releasing wave after wave of ship and character models which were very well received and enjoyed by a hungry market at the time. I can fondly remember building a model X-Wing as a child and pretending I was one of prop creators at Lucasfilm.

In the decades to follow, model building has seen a significant decline in interest and sales. The cause of this has been multifactorial. With the advent of video games and ultimately the Internet, skilled play had switched from the physical world to the virtual world. In addition, instead of model building companies trying new innovative ways to draw in consumers, they further marginalized themselves by increasing the required builders skill level on their sets, thereby marketing themselves to an ever decreasing crowd of super model building enthusiasts. The two companies who are currently producing Star Wars models were reviewed with focus on how they have risen to meet these challenges and reinvigorate the model building market.

First were the Star Wars “Metal Earth” models from Fascinations. This is a company that has impressed me over the last few years. For any who is unfamiliar with this small but popular line, the company makes realistic highly detailed laser cut metal model kits for Star Wars ships and droids. The models are beautiful once completed and are fun to build. They do however have a limited market due to their delicate nature and the manual dexterity required to build the models, once again appealing to a very limited market. They did proudly display a handsome sign for the new Star Wars film but nothing to add beyond their already released models.


Next I was to head over to Revell, the premiere and the largest model building company in the world. Along with Estes Rockets of vintage Star Wars rocket fame, they comprise the parent company Hobbico.


Classic Vehicle kits from Revell

As I approached the Revell booth I saw a big banner with the Star Wars logo with the new movie title featured. It also appeared they were featuring upcoming products for Episode VII! Much to my surprise, Revell was the only vendor who had set up a mock-up store display filled with mock-up model set boxes for The Force Awakens.

I was impressed with the sales team's ingenuity. The display and boxes were simple white cardboard made to the exact dimensions of their upcoming new products. Each mock-up had an attractive centered sticker with the words Star Wars: The Force Awakens. The smallest boxes placed in the store display by the front of the booth also had additional text in a red circle which read "try me!" beckoning Toy Fair-goers to take a closer look. Of course the boxes were empty, but that didn't make the display any less interesting.


The Force Awakens Mock-up of Mystery
Once inside, I interviewed a very responsive and impassioned team who outlined Revell's plan to restore model making to its proper place for all ages of Star Wars fans of all skill levels!

The different size model boxes were meant to represent the new sets for The Force Awakens, which will have 5 different skill levels with varying features and complexity. Level One sets will be made of a durable plastic with snap tight pieces and will be very easy to build. These sets will not require any gluing or painting and are geared toward the preliminary younger model maker. They'll also feature lights and movie sounds. They will be the first model sets ever to have these features. These designs were incorporated into the sets to make them fully functional toys once they have been built so they will appeal to the youngest fans. Complexity continues to increase with skill level. As levels increase the models become far more delicate and detailed. They begin to require glue, paint, and the placement of decals. Character figures are also added at higher levels with the biggest and most complex models having up to 7 figures.

Revell Product Display featuring additional The Force Awakens mock-ups
The team also pointed out that their line of models also appeals to parents and children who are inter-generational fans and are looking for activities to participate in together.

As I left the Revell booth I knew I had found a company who really got it. I also got a smile every time I overheard other Toy Fair attendees mumbling about Revell's "empty box" campaign. It just sounded so familiar -- sort of like Kenner's “Early Bird” empty box mailer that started the whole thing back in 1977.

Three smaller companies deserve an honorable mention for also getting it right.

Battle Ballerz by Yomega; R2-D2 Bubble Machine by Imperial; Key Chains by Quantum Mechanix

Quantum Mechanix Inc. produces screen accurate miniatures. They have a recently released line of handsome collectible Star Wars key chains which are durable and scale accurate detailed models of classic ships from the Original Trilogy made out of a pewter type metal. They will also be releasing a new line for the upcoming film.

Imperial Toy will be putting out a line of bubble making toys including a must have interactive larger scale R2-D2 which mischievously sprays people with streams of bubbles as he lights up and blabbers on. It's a natural centerpiece for kids summer parties.

Yomega is another company that is designing unique new products which have a kitsch factor that makes them fun for kids of 2015 but could have just as easily been released in 1979. They include a line of yo-yo's with unique display stands featuring main characters from the films. They are designed in bright primary colors and the graphics have a retro feel. They are also releasing a new line of small figures with removable heads that are super-balls called "Battle Ballerz." These will include a line of Star Wars characters which also appear simultaneously fresh and retro (they also bounce crazy high!).

I'm looking forward to see what the rest of 2015 brings as new secrets become revealed!

-- Yehuda Kleinman